Jeremiah faces challenges as he opens his donut stand for the first time; Mary attends church for the first time since returning home; Shelly debates whether she should contact her biological mother; Dawn wonders about going home.

At 19, Rebecca left her home and her Amish life behind. She has grown from innocent Amish girl into the strong, outspoken young wife and mother that she is today. Watch her journey to that place, which was not always so direct, or peaceful.

Archival footage and new interviews with those that know Return to Amish fan favorite Mary Schmucker best. A fresh perspective on her journey on the show, plus a recap of the events that led to Mary’s shunning from the Amish church.

Jeremiah Raber is well-known both on and off the screen as the bad boy. Through archival footage & interviews by the man himself & those who’ve experienced it all, the hour-long episode will highlight moments of Jeremiah’s journey through the years.

Former Mennonite Sabrina Burckholder was adopted into the lifestyle & eventually learned she couldn’t fully connect with it. New interviews with Sabrina & her castmates document her quest to find her place in the world, despite struggles & setbacks.

Abe Schmucker comes from a well-known Amish family but coverted to the English lifestyle, leaving the community he had been a part of his entire life. New interviews with family and friends document his journey from an Amish to an English man.

Andrew, Esther, and Katie Ann are 3 of the 5 children of Mary and Chester Schmucker who have left the Amish. As secondary characters in the series, we will chronicle their journeys with insight from their mother Mary and brother Abe.

Another year has flown by for Kate and her adorable kids. The little ones are turning six, and Kate's planning a special birthday filled with exciting celebrations. Will she be able to keep it a surprise or will she crack under the pressure?