The guys go for a consultation at a butchers and take a slab of inspiration home for lunch. Meanwhile, baby Carlo is turning 4! Hard work runs in the family, and Buddy’s nephew, Little Buddy, wants to prove he could make it at the bakery.

Buddy is asked to make a cake for Academy Award winners Common & John Legend. Plus the team must find a way to bring the beach's hot sand to the green pastures. Everything gets put on hold once Buddy finds out Mauro has been rushed to the hospital!

Buddy learns of Ralph’s secret life as a Live Action Role Player when he is asked to make a cake of a mythical griffin. Buddy creates a worldly cake for foreign exchange students. Plus, the ladies give a reluctant Mauro a makeover and a headache!

A local restaurant is celebrating its anniversary and their specialty is chicken and waffles. The guys get their cute on by creating a monster cake for a daycare center. Frankie has been the prank master for years but now the girls get their revenge!

One of America’s oldest pizzerias is turning 110 & they need a cake worthy of the milestone. Madeline takes an order, but Buddy goes rogue & it may not be a bed of roses. Buddy decides it’s time his boys learn discipline at the bakery.

Buddy puts on the pressure while making an Easter bonnet cake. Plus, the crew puts a new twist on a traditional Jewish cookie. Joey promotes German to a lead role. German quickly learns that tempers will rise just like the bread if he’s not careful.

Buddy is an assistant coach to his sons' little league team, so this cake’s got to be a home run, baby! Plus, there’s a cake order for a 50th birthday with a twist. After Mauro’s health scare, Buddy Castano wants to be prepared in an emergency.

Buddy makes a special storybook cake for the Hans Christian Andersen Storytelling Center in NY. A gymnastics team wants to throw a going-away party for a teammate with a special best friends cake. Plus, Grace disguises herself as a customer.

Amish & Ex-Amish friends and family get together at Mary Schmucker's where her husband Chester is in for a rude awakening. Andrew has a score to settle with Jeremiah, Rebecca & Sabrina are expecting big things and Kate awaits a great opportunity.

Mary takes a trip to New York City. Katie Ann tags along with Mary and Kate, and talks to a New York guy! In Pennsylvania, Abe, Rebecca, Sabrina, and Jeremiah talk babies and shunning … while Andrew and Chapel have an important appointment.

Abe and Rebecca introduce their newborn baby to the Schmucker family, but when Sabrina shows up, her pregnancy takes a scary turn. Jeremiah takes on the Schmucker ladies. And Mary argues with Chester about the church, while Chapel gets some news.

Chapel gets heartbreaking news & now must figure out a way to tell Andrew. Mary and Jeremiah showcase their business idea at the local Groundhog's Day Festival. Sabrina gets some questionable advice while Kate stays focused on her career in NYC.

A major decision is made in Andy and Chapel’s relationship, but will Abe and Rebecca be there to support? Mary takes her mind off of the family's Shunning by opening a store with Jeremiah and the wait is over for Sabrina as her baby girl is born.

Jeremiah makes an impactful decision regarding his life. Meanwhile, Andrew lets loose in an interesting way at his bachelor party while Chapel goes wedding dress shopping. And Mary and Chester unleash unexpected news.

Andrew & Chapel prepare for their big day, but nothing runs smoothly! Rebecca gives some important advice, while Abe worries about the wedding activities. Meanwhile, Jeremiah makes a final commitment & will Chester and Mary show up for the big day?

The men and women of Return to Amish are together again for a revealing one-hour reunion special. Hosted by Michelle Beadle, we'll delve into the lives of each person and hear what they've been up to since the show ended.